Dan flew in from his business trip and came right to our house so we could go get some good New Haven pizza. Sally's is the only one of the heavy hitters we had yet to try, so we decided to give it a shot. It was still relatively early (530ish) when we got there and there was a party of 6, 8, 2 and 4 waiting for tables when we arrived--not a bad line, not nearly as bad as Pepe's (or so we thought....). We are patient people, really. We waited 45 minutes and in that span of time, only the party of 6 made it inside (the party of 2 gave up). The only people coming in and out of the place were people with takeout--not a good sign. So the boys voted we leave and after waiting nearly an hour and seeing no movement, I was happy to follow.
I would like to try Sally's at some point. Really. Just not anytime soon. See BAR review for our actual dinner experience that night.